IPVanish vs. NordVPN: VPN Comparison 2020

NordVPN and IPVanish are two of the heavyweights of the VPN industry. Recently, NordVPN has passed IPVanish in popularity & growth, but does that mean they’re actually the better provider?

Each of these VPN’s has distinct advantages and unique features. This article will compare them in-depth and help you quickly decide which is the better choice for you. 

You can use the table of contents to skip to the topics/features you care about most:

Pricing

The base pricing of both these services is pretty similar. IPVanish starts at $10/month whereas NordVPN is priced slightly higher at $11.95/month.

The one year plans comparable as well, priced at $6.49/month (IPVanish) and $6.99/m (Nord). 

But the biggest discount goes to NordVPN subscribers who are willing to pay in advance for a 3-year subscription, priced at $107.55 (which works out to $2.99/month). 

Beware:  NordVPN’s 3-year deal is a limited time offer, and may go away soon!

Features

 NordVPNIPVanish
VPN apps forWindows, Mac, iOS, Android, LinuxWindows, Mac, iOS, Android, FireTV/FireStick
Manually configuration for:Routers, FireTV, Routers, Linux
Split TunnelingNoAndroid only
Stealth/ObfuscationYes (obfsproxy)Yes (OpenVPN obfuscation)
Simultaneous Connections610
Other FeaturesAd/Malware-blocking, Netflix Unblocking, Dedicated-IP servers, VPN-over-Tor, p2p-optimized servers, SOCKS ProxySOCKS Proxy

While the core VPN features of these two are nearly identical (encrypted connection to various server locations around the world), that’s not the whole story.

Each has add-on functionality beyond a simple VPN tunnel. And NordVPN really starts to set themselves apart with the available extras. 

Platforms/Operating Systems

IPVanish App Platforms
IPVanish has apps for all major platforms, including FireTV

Most of you will be using the VPN on a major OS, like Windows/Mac or a smartphone. Fortunately, both these providers have full native app support for all 4 major OS’s. 

And if you want to run a VPN directly on your (vpn-compatible) router, you can manually configure either of them to work. In our testing, IPVanish’s manually connections were a bit more stable.

One further advantage for IPVanish, is they’re the only one with a native app for Amazon’s FireTV/Firestick platform

This allows you to create a VPN connection directly on your FireTV device, and works perfectly for Kodi or other streaming applications. 

Simultaneous Connections/Devices

Most VPN’s limit the number of devices you can connect to their network simultaneously.

IPVanish allows 10, whereas NordVPN allows 6 devices at once.

Both of these are well above the industry average, which is closer to 3, so it shouldn’t be a factor unless you’re sharing one VPN account with your entire family. 

Other Features

Lets look at some of the other functionality these providers have built into their software:

NordVPN:

  • Ad-Blocking/Anti-Malware: This feature is a nice idea, though in practice it doesn’t block ads nearly as effectively as something like adblock. 
  • Netflix/Geo-restriction Unblocking: NordVPN is one of the few VPNs that works with Netflix. It can also work to unblock other geo-restricted streaming services like BBC iPlayer, Hulu, Amazon Prime, and Spotify. 
  • Special-Use Servers: You can choose from special server types with single-use cases. These include routing your VPN connection through a Tor exit node, or p2p downloads and torrenting. 

IPVanish:

IPVanish doesn’t offer much in extra functionality besides their limited obfuscation/scramble feature which may help their VPN get through restrictive firewalls. NordVPN’s obfsproxy technology works better though. 

Software

NordVPN and IPVanish both have stable, frequently updated apps for all major OS platforms.

I personally prefer the look and feel of IPVanish’s software (though the functionality is similar). 

IPVanish also allows you to pick individual cities within a country, whereas NordVPN doesn’t (one of the few VPNs with this limitation). 

IPVanish's Software

IPVanish’s Software has one of the best UI’s of any major service we’ve tested. All settings are easy to find and accessible with a few clicks.

One thing I’ve grown to appreciate is the ‘Favorite Servers’ list (just click the star) which lets you save most-used servers for easy access.

The Windows software gives access to all 4 VPN protocols, including: OpenVPN, IKEv2, SSTP and PPTP. The Mac app gives you all that except SSTP (which is windows only). 

You also get granular control of the server selection process. You can choose individual cities within a country (and even specific servers within that city). NordVPN won’t let you do this. 

IPVanish Software Settings

The settings menu lets you quickly configure the app to match your security needs. Choices include:

  • Choice of VPN protocol and Port
  • Activate the kill-switch
  • Turn on ‘Scramble’/Stealth mode (OpenVPN only)
  • Auto-reconnect
  • Auto-connect on startup

NordVPN Software

NordVPN’s software layout is similar to IPVanish’s, featuring a server selection view (map or list) as well as a settings menu. 

Selecting a server in NordVPN is as easy as choosing a location from the map view, or using the list view on the lefthand side.

You can also choose from the special-use VPN server types which include:

  • Dedicated IP: NordVPN allows users to have a unique IP address where they’re the only subscriber allowed to use it. This is an add-on service priced at $70/year
  • p2p/torrents: Special servers optimized for p2p file-sharing and BitTorrent downloads. Maximum privacy and faster download speeds.
  • Double VPN: These ‘double-hop’ servers will route you through 2 VPN exit nodes. This is mostly a marketing gimmick that results in lower speeds with minimal privacy benefits.

Currently, NordVPN does NOT offer a ‘favorite servers’ feature like IPVanish.

NordVPN Settings

NordVPN’s software has an intuitive settings menu that lets you turn certain features on/off, such as:

  • Kill Switch: NordVPN offers both an internet and app-level killswitch. You can activate either (or both).
  • Hide on LAN: Hide your computer from other devices on the same network
  • CyberSec: Built-in anti-malware and ad-blocking technology. 
  • Custom DNS: Specify your own DNS servers (like 8.8.8.8) if you prefer that to NordVPN’s
  • Obfuscation: Disguises your VPN traffic to get through restrictive firewalls. May slow speeds. 

Unblocking/Streaming

Many people like to use a VPN to access geo-restricted content from anywhere in the world. Popular uses include Spotify, Hulu, Netflix & BBC iPlayer.

Currently, NordVPN works with ALL of the above services, whereas IPVanish only works with spotify and is blocked by the other 3 (generating a proxy error message). 

Torrents & Filesharing

Both of these services are excellent choices for frequent BitTorrent users. Each has the essential ingredients to be a torrent-friendly VPN, including:

  • Zero-Log Privacy Policy
  • Torrents allowed on all servers
  • SOCKS5 Proxy Included
  • P2P Usage explicitly allowed

In fact, both NordVPN and IPVanish score a 10 out of 10 on or torrent-friendliness rankings. 

Winner: Tie

Privacy & Logs

A VPNs privacy policy should be  a critical part of your selection process. Users, and especially frequent torrenters, should always choose a VPN with a true no-logs policy.

So what logs do NordVPN & IPVanish keep?

NordVPN Logging Policy

Here’s NordVPN’s logging policy from their privacy policy

…we have a strict no-logs policy when it comes to seeing user activity online: being based in Panama, which is internet friendly country and does not require data storage or reporting, we are empowered to deny any third party requests. Period.

So NordVPN also appears to be a true Zero-Log VPN. We like that their privacy policy is even more specific, and promising that they are ’empowered to deny and 3rd-party requests’ thanks to Panama’s privacy laws. 

Offshore VPNs (in coutries like Panama, Sweden, Switzerland etc…) are considred to offer greater privacy and perhaps additional protection from extra-national surveilance agencies like the NSA and Five-eyes spy alliance. 

IPVanish Logging Policy

Here’s IPVanish’s logging policy (from their privacy policy)

“IPVanish does not collect or log any traffic or use of its Virtual Private Network service”

While the terms ‘traffic or use’ are a bit vague, we did get in touch with an IPVanish employee who indicated that IPV doesn’t store IP addresses or similar invasive connection logs. In other words, IPVanish appears to be a true zero-log provider.

It’s worth noting the IPVanish is located the USA. Data retention laws in the USA do not apply to VPN services, so IPVanish can choose not to keep any logs whatsoever. However, all US-based companies could be compelled to secretly comply with a National Security Letter and divulge subscriber information (if any is kept). This isn’t really a concern for anybody that isn’t being actively pursued by a government agency. 

Possible Concerns:
IPVanish was at the center of a controversy about their logging policy, when it was revealed that the US Department of Homeland Security was able to identify one of their users in Indiana. 

However it is not clear whether IPVanish actually violated their logging policy (as their competitors claim) or if the DHS was responsible for the data collection, using Wireshark on a similar packet-inspection technology.

In either case, it shows the limitations of a privacy policy when faced with government intervention. 

Who offers better privacy?

While both these services advertise a ‘no-logs’ guarantee, NordVPN is better set up to guarantee it.

Their Panama-based jurisdiction gives them some protection from subpoenas regarding user data, and we haven’t heard any reports or cases of specific user data being exposed (unlike IPVanish).

Winner: NordVPN

Security & Encryption

The core function of a VPN is to secure & encrypt your data in transit. Lets see how IPVanish & NordVPN stack up in this area:

Encryption Strength & Algorithm

Both NordVPN & IPVanish uses 256-bit AES Encryption by default. This is the industry standard for high-security encryption algorithms.

For the initial key exchange between your device and the VPN server, NordVPN uses 4096-bit keys (stronger) and IPVanish uses 2048-bit (weaker). Both are considering secure in practical terms, and IPVanish’s smaller key-size gives them a speed advantage (quicker connection times). 

When it comes to data authentication (making sure an attacker can’t inject malicious data into your VPN packets) both use SHA-256 (which is highly secure). 

 

Kill Switch

Both services have an internet-level kill-switch (which will shut down your internet connectivity if the VPN disconnects). 

Additionally, NordVPN offers an app-level kill switch which will close programs you specify when the VPN drops. Though it sounds nifty, in practical terms it may be less useful, and is noticeably slower to react that the near-instant internet kill switch. 

NordVPN's application kill switch

Other Security Features

NordVPN has a new ‘CyberSec’ feature that is meant to block ads and protect users from malware. It’s a behind-the-scenes feature, so it’s a bit hard to tell whether it’s working (no notification when malware is blocked).

In general, it’s nice to have but probably not as useful as a purpose-built tool like Malwarebytes or a good Antivirus.

Winner: NordVPN

We give NordVPN the slight edge here, thanks to their stronger handshake encryption, Cybersec anti-malware, and dual kill-switch options. 

Speedtests & Performance

How do NordVPN & IPVanish match up for overall speed, both on nearby servers as well as international server locations. 

We ran our tests on a 100mbps connection to see how they matched up:

 NordVPN DLNordVPN ULIPVanish DLIPVanish UL
USA67.78 Mbps107.52 Mbps58.40 Mbps44.67 Mbps
Canada51.70 Mbps71.05 Mbps89.29 Mbps39.08 Mbps
Netherlands (p2p)51.42 Mbps20.44 Mbps51.43 Mbps12.61 Mbps

NordVPN Speed

NordVPN Speedtest (Canada)
NordVPN Canada Speed
NordVPN Netherlands Speed Test
NordVPN Netherlands Speed (P2P)
NordVPN USA Speedtest
NordVPN USA Speed (NYC)

IPVanish Speed

IPVanish Canada Speedtest
IPVanish Speedtest (Canada)
IPVanish Netherlands Speed
IPVanish Speedtest (Netherlands/p2p)
IPVanish USA Speedtest
IPVanish Speedtest (USA)

Winner: IPVanish

Conclusion: NordVPN or IPVanish (who's the best?)

NordVPN Pros

NordVPN Cons

You should choose NordVPN if…

  • You want the best value
  • Your connection speed is slower than 50mbps
  • Country-level server selection is enough
  • You want audited proof of no logs

IPVanish Pros

IPVanish Cons

You should choose IPVanish if…

  • Speed is the most important thing
  • You’re willing to pay for better performance & stability
  • You want to use your VPN for FireStick/Kodi
  • You trust U.S. based companies more ones with shadowy ownership

Ryan McCarthy

Ryan is the editor and head reviewer. He's been a tech geek and digital privacy enthusiast since the Y2k freakout in '99. When not writing BitTorrent tutorials, he can usually be found sipping a lager or playing pickup football (the real kind).

Leave a Comment